The CORRECT definition for "barbecue" ...

QSis

Grill Master
Staff member
NCT Patron
.... is food that is cooked low and slow over wood and/or charcoal.

It may also be an event where the above food is served.

It is NOT a cookout where someone serves burgers and dogs.

It is NOT a gas grill.

Would anyone care to add, edit, or debate the above? Just cuz we CAN! :wink:

Lee
 
When I grew up. the word 'barbecue' was used as such: "Would you like to come to a barbecue this weekend?" If you showed up, picnic tables would be set up in the yard, and someone would be cooking over a charcoal or gas grill. You'd get burgers, franks, chicken, sausage, steaks or ribs, potato salad, corn on the cob and watermelon.

Older and more worldly that I now am, I use the word as I was raised, but also mean a huge hunk of meat, cooked low and slow, pulled apart and served on some really great bread with a variety of sauces mopped over it.

Generally, I'll use it as a term to describe meat if I am writing a menu, such as 'we're having a memphis bbq special'....

But, I'll still invite people to my home by saying 'wanna come to a barbecue?'
 
Well, I take your definition of barbecue Wart. I never really knew the term when I grew up. We used to call out eating with meat cooked over the fire a "braai". There used steak, sausages, eandless meats & fish but definitely more a grill then long slow cooking.
When we came to the UK, we did take up the barbecue because the grilled offerings of burger or sausage seemed so pathetic next to our braai experience.
 
Being a Yankee we used the BBQ term pretty fast and loose for pretty much any outdoor style cooking....

BBQ or "grilling" always got the bums rush. I never understood how a family that put food so front and center fresh ingredients from local shops.. only the best meats, pastas, cheeses and made everything by hand... the second food moved to the grill stopped giving a damn and went to frozen burgers cheap steaks blackened to carbon accompanied by cheapo rolls wax cheese and store bought salads and slaw... this involved a-lot of my granfather cursing over a busted old gas grill that was perptually running out of gas

this crap was mostly fed to us kids while the "adults" stuck with sausage and peppers, light pasta dishes, and cold antipasto

Texas was a revelation... I had never had anything like this... Here BBQ was not a term to be taken lightly but referred to something deeply ingrained in culture myth and legend...deep complicated flavors and secrect sauces... here incorrect use of the work Q could get peoples panties in a bunch and for good reason
 
I understand the word barbeque means low and slow, now that I have a cooker... or "smoker".
But..... when I grew up we called burgers and dogs done outside cooking or grilling out. If we were doing a chicken, always done with BBQ sauce applied, we called that a BBQ. So I'll interchange them.
And while I made an effort to call my WSM a cooker or pit after being corrected, I still see a lot of people using the word smoker, or smoking meat, so I'm pretty sure we know what is being referred to.
 
bbq is a special word for english speaking areas... here in Germany we invite "zum grillen" (for grilling)..
that means coal ist heated, sausages, Steaks, Fish, Veggies - whatever - are grilled on the grill...
very simple.

There usually is some mixed salad, potatoe salad, Zaziki and/or bread served with it..
 
.... is food that is cooked low and slow over wood and/or charcoal.

It may also be an event where the above food is served.

It is NOT a cookout where someone serves burgers and dogs.

It is NOT a gas grill.

Would anyone care to add, edit, or debate the above? Just cuz we CAN! :wink:

Lee

not exactlly if you want to get technical...lol

there is no clear defintion....

and i quote.... i know most of this but didnt feel like typing it all out..its a very nice read though

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Barbecue i only copied some of it..there is way more to read

The origins of both the activity of barbecue cooking and the word itself are somewhat obscure. Most etymologists believe that barbecue derives ultimately from the word barbacoa found in the language of the Taíno people of the Caribbean. The word translates as "sacred fire pit" and is also spelled barbacoa.[2] The word describes a grill for cooking meat, consisting of a wooden platform resting on sticks.
Traditional barbacoa involves digging a hole in the ground and placing some meat (usually a whole goat) with a pot underneath it, so that the juices can make a hearty broth. It is then covered with maguey leaves and coal and set alight. The cooking process takes a few hours.
There is ample evidence that both the word and cooking technique migrated out of the Caribbean and into other languages and cultures, with the word moving from Caribbean dialects into Spanish, then French and English. The Oxford English Dictionary cites the first recorded use of the word in the English language in 1697 by the British buccaneer William Dampier. [3]
The word evolved into its modern English spelling of barbecue and may also be found spelled as barbeque, bar-b-q or bbq.[4] In the southeastern United States, the word barbecue is used predominantly as a noun referring to roast pork, while in the southwestern states, cuts of beef are often cooked.
The word barbecue has attracted several inaccurate origins from folk etymology. An often-repeated claim is that the word is derived from the French language. The story goes that French visitors to the Caribbean saw a pig being cooked whole and described the method as barbe à queue, meaning "from beard to tail". The French word for barbecue is also barbecue, and the "beard to tail" explanation is regarded as false by most language experts. The only merit is that it relies on the similar sound of the words, a feature common in folk-etymology explanations.[5] Another claim states that the word BBQ came from the time when roadhouses and beer joints with pool tables advertised "Bar, Beer and Cues". According to this tale, the phrase was shortened over time to BBCue, then BBQ.[6]
 
but are the prawns large or small, or an irish or aussie subspecies?

is the gravy brown, red, or some other color?
 
Interesting. When we grill burgers, hot dogs, steaks, brats, chicken etc ... we call it a cookout. Sometimes we cookout BBQ chicken or BBQ ribs. :D
 
Being from OK, I agree with Qsis about the definition of "BBQ". However, being the moderately-travelled and worldly-learned geek that I am, I have come to realize that the term "BBQ" means different things to different people. Most of those different definitions have already been stated.

My MIL, rest her soul, always asked me how many hot dogs, burgers, and steaks I had if I said I was going to "BBQ" something.

I make an effort at home, online, and at work, to say "grilling a steak", or "smoking (insert meat here)".

My cooker at home is a combo unit (I'll try and get some pics up soon). It's the Char-Griller unit that's available at Lowe's. I have the side-firebox attachment. When I first bought the thing, I would make a small fire on the right side of the cooking chamber, and have the meat on the left side, away from direct heat. Now, I light the fire in the SFB, and keep meat in the cooking chamber, although I usually try NOT to have something right up against the right side, as that is hotter. If I'm grilling, I like the fire in the cooking chamber.

I got in to "Q" when I was living up in Michigan. I just couldn't find a place that had decent Q, so I had to teach myself how to make my own. Now that I'm in OK, I see no need to line some other person's pockets, when I can do this at home for a fraction of the cost.
 
OK the way I see it is this. BBQ is in the middle between Smoking and Grilling. Grilling is high heat for short periods of time. BBQ is slow and low. And Smoking is slower and lower than BBQing. Some will say that smoking is BBQing, but I think there is a distinction. One will BBQ for a few hours where as smoking may take 10-12 and beyond.

And to jumble it all up even more is indirecting. Which to me is a combination of smoking and BBQing. It's done at higher temps than smoking and for less time. But when I indirect I generally use smoke wood to impart a nice flavor but don't cook it long enough to get a smoke ring.


Now if you really want to screw things up, how about the fact that one BBQ's on a BBQ grill. So by cooking on a grill, isn't it all grilling? Yeah, my brain is starting to hurt!!
 
Yea we use the term pretty loosely up here as well. You can say grilling or BBQ'ing to people and they see it as the same thing.
But, I have always thought of grilling as direct and high heat, or cooking on a grill instead of a stove. BBQ I always think of low and slow, and smoking is well smoking LOL.
Where I get mixed up is when I grill something and brush on BBQ sauce, am I then grilling BBQ? LOL
 
I agree with the technical aspects Qsis brings up.

BBQ = Low and slow with indirect heat
Grilling = Fast direct heat

Smoking = BBQ

Still BBQ is used rather loosely around here, and I’m down south where some people will hang you for using the term wrong. But, when you grill chicken and then slather on the BBQ sauce, it’s much easier to say it’s “BBQ chicken” rather than “Grilled Chicken glazed with a sweet and smokey tomato based sauce”. :lol:

That's why, down here, we typically use “Smoking” and “Grilling” to differentiate the two.
 
Yea we use the term pretty loosely up here as well. You can say grilling or BBQ'ing to people and they see it as the same thing.
But, I have always thought of grilling as direct and high heat, or cooking on a grill instead of a stove. BBQ I always think of low and slow, and smoking is well smoking LOL.
Where I get mixed up is when I grill something and brush on BBQ sauce, am I then grilling BBQ? LOL

:applause:

two kinds of smoking...cold and hot

The targeted cold smoking temperature range is between 80 degrees F
and 100 degrees F and require cooking when u want to eat it...

Hot smoking occurs within the range of 165°F/74°C to 185°F/85°C and they are typically safe to eat without further cooking

BBQ temps are best when u can keep them at 225°F or close to it
 
Top