Brisket Prices

Comparing corned beef brisket to fresh brisket is like comparing beef jerky to prime rib. They may start out the same, but the end results have little in common.

One reason brisket may be on sale right now is because sundown tonight is the beginning of Rosh Hashanah, the Jewish New Year. Brisket is considered one of the most desirable cuts of kosher beef (because it comes from a portion of the cow that's so far from the...how shall I say...less clean portion of the beast). If prepared properly, brisket makes a wonderful pot-roast type main course for the celebratory meals -- very lean if you remove the outer layer of fat before serving, and very flavorful.

This is one of my favorite recipes for brisket, very similar to what my Jewish mother-in-law used to prepare (also attached in printable format):

FRIDAY NIGHT BRISKET
Los Angeles Times, March 28, 2007

Adapted from Joan Nathan's Jewish Holiday Cookbook.
Total time: 5 hours and 25 minutes, plus cooling time
Servings: 8 to 10

1 (4- to 5-pound) brisket
2 (1-ounce) packets onion soup mix
1½ cups Heinz Chili Sauce
6 cloves garlic
1½ pounds carrots

1. Heat the oven to 350 degrees. Place the meat fat-side up in a large
Dutch oven. Sprinkle the onion soup mix over the meat. Cover with
the chile sauce and 2 cups of water, or more if needed to almost
cover the meat. Crush the garlic cloves and add to the liquid (they will
dissolve, so no need to chop).

2. Cover the pan and cook for 4 hours. Check every 30 minutes to be
sure there is sufficient liquid in pan. Let the brisket cool for about 45
minutes and refrigerate overnight. Then skim the fat off the meat.

3. About 1½ hours before you wish to serve the brisket, heat the oven to
350 degrees. Remove the brisket to a cutting board and slice it thinly
across the grain. Trim, peel and cut the carrots into 1½-by-2-inch
sticks. Cook the brisket and carrots covered for 1 hour, until the
brisket is heated through and the carrots are fork tender.
(Alternatively, the brisket can be completed the same day: While the
brisket is cooling for 45 minutes, trim, peel and cut the carrots into
1½-by-2-inch sticks. Remove the brisket and slice it thinly across the
grain. Skim the fat off the top of the liquid, add the sliced brisket back
to the pan with the carrots, cover and bake at 350 degrees for 1 more
hour, or until carrots are fork tender.) Serve on a platter.

Each of 10 servings: 346 calories; 44 grams protein; 18 grams
carbohydrates; 4 grams fiber; 9 grams fat; 3 grams saturated fat; 87 mg.
cholesterol; 1,173 mg. sodium.
 

Attachments

Comparing corned beef brisket to fresh brisket is like comparing beef jerky to prime rib .

Well, THAT analogy might be a tad extreme, Doug!

I don't think anyone was comparing the two forms of brisket, anyway - questions were asked about each of them.

Lee
 
Doug that is close to how we prepare it with some differences. We don't use the chili sauce and carrots. We use onions as well as mushroom soup though under the brisket in a roasting pan covered loosely with tin foil. We also set the oven to 375 for about 30 to 40 minutes then turn it back the oven to 325 to finish cooking, which is about 30 minutes a lb.
 
brisket is a funny thing ... prepacked ones with the spices have been
covered ..
where i am at .. you can get three types ..
point .. flat .. and packer ...
the point is nice .. it has much more fat ..
you want a 1/4 inch layer for smoking ..
flat .. it has made many a smoker turn their back on the
holy grail of smoking ..
and the packer .. usually around 25 lbs ..
mostly for catering or competing ...
3.49\lb is a decent price here ...
i have tried brisket twice .. both times paying
4.74\lb .. and very dissapointing .. first time was a flat ..
waste of money .. second was a point .. learning process ..
brisket is now a days an expensive cut of meat to learn how to smoke ..
not like a butt .. its hard to mess one of those up ...
if you do it right .. its out of the ball park ...
a couple degrees off on your heat ...
it jerky ..
 
brisket is a funny thing ... prepacked ones with the spices have been
covered ..
where i am at .. you can get three types ..
point .. flat .. and packer ...
the point is nice .. it has much more fat ..
you want a 1/4 inch layer for smoking ..
flat .. it has made many a smoker turn their back on the
holy grail of smoking ..
and the packer .. usually around 25 lbs ..
mostly for catering or competing ...
3.49\lb is a decent price here ...
i have tried brisket twice .. both times paying
4.74\lb .. and very dissapointing .. first time was a flat ..
waste of money .. second was a point .. learning process ..
brisket is now a days an expensive cut of meat to learn how to smoke ..
not like a butt .. its hard to mess one of those up ...
if you do it right .. its out of the ball park ...
a couple degrees off on your heat ...
it jerky ..

Brisket is tough to smoke right and if doing a large one be prepared to man the smoker for about 24 hours. The are a tough cut of meat to cook till tender but it can be done be it in an oven or a smoker. I know when I make it you can cut it with a fork but again it really depends on how long and slow it is cooked. Pork on the other hand is a lot more forgiving when it comes to smoking while not very if done in an oven as it tends to dry out if cooked too long.
 
Bucky, just a point of clarity, a "true" pastrami is made with the plate not a brisket. The plate is the roast version of short ribs. It's usually fattier than a brisket..


thanks for the info, uncon. i think so many people have heard about "a nice, lean, pastrami" that briskets are used more often nowadays.

here's a pic of my last grilled corned beef. it was a thing of beauty. the flavor exploded in your mouth. very different than simply boiling it.




img3599z.jpg
 
thanks qsis.

if you like a boiled corned beef, you've gotta try grilling one. my next attempt will be roasting one with a fruit glaze. just need to think of a fruit that'll stand up to a salty roast.
 
naw, not wagyu. i think it was a "cook's brand" corned beef. <gasp> a store bought, vacu-packed dealio.

and that would be a misnomer to call it marbling. it's really just deliciously brined fat held together by a little meat. if i'd boiled it, most of that fat would have gone into the water.
 
Here are more brisket pictures.



Me and one of my BBQ partners, Dave, with two unprepped packer (whole) briskets.



This is a smoked FLAT cut. Note the leaner meat. It was one of the best brisket cuts I've ever smoked, but it was at HOME and not competition (we enter slices of the flat in competition, because it's more difficult to get right, and judges love it).



This is a typical competition entry of brisket flat slices.
 
BBQ brisket is a whole 'nother thing, wonderful stuff, but no real comparison to corned beef brisket.
 
Well, THAT analogy might be a tad extreme, Doug!

I don't think anyone was comparing the two forms of brisket, anyway - questions were asked about each of them.

Lee
Hardly! If anything, it's an understatement. Corned beef brisket and fresh beef brisket are nothing alike. No way, no how.
 
thanks qsis.

if you like a boiled corned beef, you've gotta try grilling one. my next attempt will be roasting one with a fruit glaze. just need to think of a fruit that'll stand up to a salty roast.
cranberries or tart cherries? salty beef with sweet and tangy cranberry or tart cherry glaze sounds yummy to me.
 
Hardly! If anything, it's an understatement. Corned beef brisket and fresh beef brisket are nothing alike. No way, no how.

Again, no one was comparing them. At all. They were asking questions about both.

My comment to you was regarding your extreme comparison between jerky and prime rib. LOL!

Lee
 
Top